March 13 Class

Hey, it's Erin.

We started off today with the usual questions about research, then moved on to getting back our research proposals. They are not set in stone because your research can take you in other directions, so they do not need a bunch of disclaimers. We then continued our discussion about the national anthem as Mr. Lazarow brought up Jimmy Hendrick's version of the "Star-Spangled Banner", specifically to ask the question of why the electric guitar version (which could be thought of as a translation) was okay, but there was an uproar when the national anthem was translated into Spanish. Jasmine suggested that electric guitar is a part of American culture, which made that version more acceptable in certain people's eyes because some people think that English should be the official language of the U.S., and thus would dislike the national anthem sung in a foreign language rather than English.

Ashley changed the direction of the discussion by bringing up "Arnold Schwarzenegger's Dream." Someone (I think it was Ashley) mentioned that he spoke of America in such glowing terms. The reason of course is that Arnold Schwarzenegger has found great success in America, going from body builder to actor to governor of California. The question that was subsequently brought up was whether his incredible success was due to the opportunity America had to offer, the hard work and drive that he brought, or just luck, simply being at the right place at the right time. Arka thought that it was a combination of all three. Cristy thought that hard work was necessary to success, although there are cases where that is not true (someone works and works and works and never gets anywhere or the person that seems to have everything handed to them on a plate).

The discussion of the American Dream then took another turn when what some consider to be the "ultimate" American Dream: to be president of the United States. Because Arnold was born in Austria, he (as well as countless others) cannot become president. This standard (to be born in the United States) has been up for change, specifically because of Arnold Schwarzenegger. Should it be changed? Is it fair to deny someone his or her dream simply because couldn't help where they were born? Is that saying that they are not "true" citizens? When discussing why some people agree with that requirement, Stephanie brought up that people always have a special place in their heart for where they were born. Mr. Lazarow replied that everyone has biases one way or another. Donna also brought up how sometimes parents try to get their child to assimilate even if their child wants to learn more about their heritage because they feel that that will hurt their child's chances.

All in all, it was another productive and interesting class. Remember, 20 source cards due on Tuesday. And of course, AP money deadline is tomorrow!!!!! See everyone on Friday :)